The Sydney Swans; the presumption of innocence; and the management of risk in sport
“The tax office has commenced court proceedings against me for a Director Penalty Notice (DPN) debt. What can I do?”
“I had no idea it was a phishing scam, I thought I was filling in a survey.” Which case won?
The case of a man who fell victim to a phishing scam reads as a textbook example of cyber fraud. The man received an email inviting him to participate in an online cash survey. The email contained a web link and instructions to click on the link to complete the survey.
As part of the survey, the man was asked to provide his credit card number, which he did. Unbeknownst to him, by doing so, he made this information available remotely to the scammers who had sent him the email.
The fraudsters then asked the man to enter one-off PIN codes sent by his financial services provider to his mobile phone, which he did.
Doyle’s Guide 2026 recognises Stacks lawyers across New South Wales
“You can’t end the contract, I’ve got an option agreement to buy the land.” Which case won?
A landowner who owned a large block of land in West Pennant Hills, in Sydney’s north west, was approached by a developer who indicated he was interested in purchasing the land under a put and call option agreement.
This is an agreement for the sale of land allowing the developer to compel the landowner to complete the contract once certain conditions have been met.
The relevant conditions were that development approval would need to be granted first, before the developer would commit to completing the purchase. The developer was responsible for obtaining the development approval.
And just when you thought it was safe to go outside – the advent of smart glasses
“I lost my eyesight and my hearing because my GP missed the meningitis symptoms.” Which case won?
In early September 2008, a woman, who was then 43, began suffering from neck pain and headaches. She consulted a chiropractor, but the pain and headaches continued.
The woman consulted her GP due to worsening neck pain, severe headaches and facial flushing. The GP advised her to continue with chiropractic treatment and with the pain medication she was currently taking.
Lemon law shields buyers of defective new vehicles
“Can the police revoke my firearms licence because they found cannabis plants in my backyard?” Which case won?
A man living in regional NSW held a Category AB firearms licence, authorising the use of certain rifles and shotguns.
He primarily used his firearms for recreational shooting and for pest and vermin control on a rural property owned by his neighbours.
At the age of 16 he had suffered a serious spinal injury in a workplace accident. The injury caused him to suffer chronic back pain, which he relieved by using cannabis.
When the party’s over – breaking up a polyamorous relationship
I’ve received a Director Penalty Notice. What is it? And what do I do now?
“My sentence for drug supply is excessive. I’m already punished by media attention and the loss of my career.” Which case won?
A case on appeal in NSW focused on whether a sentence handed down for drug supply charges was excessive.
In June 2015, a young man was apprehended by police and found to be in possession of a substantial quantity of illegal recreational drugs. This included 17 MDMA tablets, 100 MDA tablets, 338.8 grams of 1,4-butanediol (or “bute”, an alternative to the drug GHB), and 1.3728 kilograms of gamma-butyrolactone (GBL), as well as $3,000 in cash.
The man was charged with two counts of supply of a prohibited drug and one count of supply of a commercial quantity of a prohibited drug, along with other offences.
“He never revoked the will which left his estate to me.” Which case won?
A NSW case revolved around the question of whether or not a man had revoked a will, and whether his intentions were better reflected by a newer, unsigned will.
In the years prior to his death at the age of 87, the man instructed his solicitor on a number of occasions to prepare a draft will for him. It was the man’s practice to attend to the signing and witnessing of a draft will received from his solicitor himself, prior to returning the completed will to his solicitor for safe keeping.
In 2015 the man made a will leaving everything to his friend of many years’ standing.
Laws banning Nazi symbols and salutes lead to penalties
Sovereign citizen gobbledygook never wins
Is your business ready for anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing (AML/CTF)?
“She was already in negotiations with our competitor while still working for us.” Which case won?
A case heard in Victoria concerned a finance executive who was taken to court by her former employer after she resigned and went to work for a competitor. Aware she had been in job negotiations while it still employed her, the former employer sought to enforce the restraint clause in her contract.
A large clothing retailer with outlets all over Australia employed a chief financial officer (CFO), based in Victoria. The CFO had worked in finance at a senior level in various industries, including apparel retail, although some considerable time prior to the events giving rise to the litigation.
The CFO started working for the retailer in January 2016. She and the company had negotiated an employment contract which included a clause purporting to restrict her ability to work for the retailer’s competitors after her employment came to an end.
While the CFO’s salary package was substantial (close to half a million dollars per annum), the contract contained a probationary period provision. It was asserted in evidence that this was because while the CFO had previously worked in apparel retail, she had not done so for some time and was instead coming from the health care industry.